Showing posts with label book. Show all posts
Showing posts with label book. Show all posts
Sunday, May 6, 2018
Book Review: The Railway Man by Eric Lomax
As a book recommended by some publication (don't remember which one) that covered something to the effect of "books about WWII that you should read" or similar this work should have been better.
Not that it isn't interesting or contain a remarkable series of events...its just not that compelling a read.
By that I mean the author does not have his own voice. Anyone subjected to the awful series of events he was--captured by the Japanese, put to work near (not on) the Burma-Siam railway (of Bridge on the River Kwai infamy), tortured by the Japanese secret police, imprisoned in some of the worst hell holes of POW note, and years later reconnecting with one of his interrogators (not torturors as the book often erroneously states and is put forth to be as this interrogator was just that...an inquisitor and translator, never putting a hand on the author)--could have retold this work. Again, not that it isn't a remarkable retelling, but its simply that, not a "work".
Little analysis nor much "art" here. Placing a tape recorder in front of the author and having him simply give his biography would largely result in the same. Further, his interest in railways and trains as a youth and then his tangential "work" on the Burma-Siam railway does not come off as an effective thread by which the work can be connected from beginning to end. It comes off forced and not valuable to the tale...distracting more than anything.
None of this is to take away from Eric Lomax's internal fortitude in the face of awful conditions, brutal torture, absence of hope, etc. He deserves all the credit he received for having the courage to persevere as well as to forgive his former captor. His retelling of these events just does not amount to an engaging read or shed light on heretofore unknown events.
Sunday, February 18, 2018
Book Review: Tenth of December by George Saunders
I can't help but feeling this collection comes off better in short doses...as in the magazines it was originally printed in--The New Yorker and Harper's primarily. I can easily see reading these in a magazine during a transitory visit to an airport or in a 20 minute trip to a library. A sort of brief distraction if you will, that makes you pause ever so briefly to wonder if your own existence aligns with those of his characters but ultimately concluding that while I agree with his view of the modern world, his characters are not those with whom I can find enough of myself in, nor are significantly attached to in the time I spend with them to care about their plights.
While I enjoyed the stories, all of which are modern in topic and some of which border on science fiction, I found none of them particularly resonant with the exception of the titular work in which a disaffected young boy saves the life of a suicidal older man and vice versa. Never did I imagine myself buying a dog from a meth-head trailer trash family or a lower-middle class father trying to keep up with the Jonses by hanging poor immigrants from my trees as a decoration.
The rest of the collection touches on returning soldiers, manipulation of mental states, modern suburbia, etc. which are all typically in my wheelhouse for interest...I just never found an emotional connection to any of the characters outside of the aforementioned two.
Saunders is by all accounts an awarded novelist and short story writer so maybe it was I who didn't bring something to the table that would allow the connection with his works, but for whatever reason, it wasn't there beyond the time it takes to consume the media.
While I enjoyed the stories, all of which are modern in topic and some of which border on science fiction, I found none of them particularly resonant with the exception of the titular work in which a disaffected young boy saves the life of a suicidal older man and vice versa. Never did I imagine myself buying a dog from a meth-head trailer trash family or a lower-middle class father trying to keep up with the Jonses by hanging poor immigrants from my trees as a decoration.
The rest of the collection touches on returning soldiers, manipulation of mental states, modern suburbia, etc. which are all typically in my wheelhouse for interest...I just never found an emotional connection to any of the characters outside of the aforementioned two.
Saunders is by all accounts an awarded novelist and short story writer so maybe it was I who didn't bring something to the table that would allow the connection with his works, but for whatever reason, it wasn't there beyond the time it takes to consume the media.
Wednesday, January 11, 2017
Book Review: Dance of the Dwarfs by Geoffrey Household
Having read two previous Household books it is clear to me now that Household is a master of the "chase" or "hunt" genre. All three involve a mystery of some kind whereby a protagonist is hunted down or haunted by an unknown or at least undetailed outside force.
In the two prior novels I had consumed, Rogue Male and Watcher in the Shadows, these outside forces had manifested themselves as other men, with both works selecting England as their location. Dance of the Dwarfs trades man for a large otter (yes...an otter...) and England for South America, spinning its tale in the format of a diary in which Dr. Owen Dawnay recounts his time spent in the backwater of Brazil.
You may laugh at the idea of a suspense novel where an otter plays the foil to the human protagonist (an English, government sponsored scientist exploring the use of various terrain for farming) but the strength of the work is such that by the time our human storyteller meets his fate you don't view the opposing mustelids as a joke.
This work is not likely one that would remain in its current form if produced today given the protagonist is "gifted" an Indian girl of 15 (20 years his junior) who has already been passed amongst a few prior owners and who is immediately bedded by our narrator. Sort of like how Hendrix's "Hey Joe" would never get made today. Many of the narrator's expressed viewpoints would not be allowed today and never get past an editor who I can hear saying to Household "You just can't write that these days!!" Perhaps Household is attempting to tell us something of his view of the white man's possession and use of the wild places the story inhabits as the more his main character falls in love with this Indian girl, the more endangered and closer to death he becomes.
There are also angles of criticism here regarding communism, science, religion, and feminist perspectives. That the work has such depth despite being "only" a horror novel of sorts is impressive. While not quite the work in terms of the suspense or detailed environment it creates compared to the earlier Household tales mentioned above it is still a solid addition to his library.
As a side note, I guess there was a "loosely based" movie made of this novel back in 1983 "starring" Peter Fonda and John Amos...it was decidedly a B movie affair, transformed the mustelids of Household's imagination into "lizard-men" and has not yet been deemed worthy of being offered on DVD though
In the two prior novels I had consumed, Rogue Male and Watcher in the Shadows, these outside forces had manifested themselves as other men, with both works selecting England as their location. Dance of the Dwarfs trades man for a large otter (yes...an otter...) and England for South America, spinning its tale in the format of a diary in which Dr. Owen Dawnay recounts his time spent in the backwater of Brazil.You may laugh at the idea of a suspense novel where an otter plays the foil to the human protagonist (an English, government sponsored scientist exploring the use of various terrain for farming) but the strength of the work is such that by the time our human storyteller meets his fate you don't view the opposing mustelids as a joke.
This work is not likely one that would remain in its current form if produced today given the protagonist is "gifted" an Indian girl of 15 (20 years his junior) who has already been passed amongst a few prior owners and who is immediately bedded by our narrator. Sort of like how Hendrix's "Hey Joe" would never get made today. Many of the narrator's expressed viewpoints would not be allowed today and never get past an editor who I can hear saying to Household "You just can't write that these days!!" Perhaps Household is attempting to tell us something of his view of the white man's possession and use of the wild places the story inhabits as the more his main character falls in love with this Indian girl, the more endangered and closer to death he becomes.
There are also angles of criticism here regarding communism, science, religion, and feminist perspectives. That the work has such depth despite being "only" a horror novel of sorts is impressive. While not quite the work in terms of the suspense or detailed environment it creates compared to the earlier Household tales mentioned above it is still a solid addition to his library.
As a side note, I guess there was a "loosely based" movie made of this novel back in 1983 "starring" Peter Fonda and John Amos...it was decidedly a B movie affair, transformed the mustelids of Household's imagination into "lizard-men" and has not yet been deemed worthy of being offered on DVD though
Thursday, December 22, 2016
The Forgotten Soldier by Guy Sajer
Haven't posted anything here in a while but wanted to for this book.
This work recounts the author's time in the German army during WWII. Involved in the initial stages of Germany's retreat in the East all the way to the end of the war, the author experienced the worst of what the conflict had to offer and describes it in full detail.
The blood, the cold, the depravity, the cowardice, the heroism, the anger, hatred, frustration, disillusionment, starvation, mutilation...its all here. Sajer doesn't shy away from his own failings and the work comes across as a beautifully honest recount of his service. Which isn't to say the book should be taken as a pure academic recap of the German effort of WWII in the East. It isn't. It has inaccuracies as others have pointed out. That's not the overall point and Sajer has been one to say so.
Its more of an emotional synopsis of his experience and the reader comes away with the feeling that no one should have survived what he went through and certainly no one sane could have.
This work is not one to delve into the issues behind Germany's efforts, there is really little mention of Hitler and zero mention of the Holocaust or other well known events of the war and its evils. If you are looking for that or for Sajer to fall on his knees and beg forgiveness for having fought on the losing side, this is not your book.
If you are looking for an epically honest depiction of the German grunt's viewpoint of how it felt to be driven backwards by the unstoppable masses of Russian soldiers over a period of years through the worst of living conditions, then this is more appropriate.
I have not read a more vivid description of the obscene nature of ground warfare anywhere. Nowhere else have I felt it better shown the indifferent nature of combatants as to their superiors motives or overarching goals, rather these are purely men fighting for the man next to them and merely in the hope of living to see another day. Politics and preaching are absent here...as you come to realize, they are in all trenches.
This work recounts the author's time in the German army during WWII. Involved in the initial stages of Germany's retreat in the East all the way to the end of the war, the author experienced the worst of what the conflict had to offer and describes it in full detail.
The blood, the cold, the depravity, the cowardice, the heroism, the anger, hatred, frustration, disillusionment, starvation, mutilation...its all here. Sajer doesn't shy away from his own failings and the work comes across as a beautifully honest recount of his service. Which isn't to say the book should be taken as a pure academic recap of the German effort of WWII in the East. It isn't. It has inaccuracies as others have pointed out. That's not the overall point and Sajer has been one to say so.
Its more of an emotional synopsis of his experience and the reader comes away with the feeling that no one should have survived what he went through and certainly no one sane could have.
This work is not one to delve into the issues behind Germany's efforts, there is really little mention of Hitler and zero mention of the Holocaust or other well known events of the war and its evils. If you are looking for that or for Sajer to fall on his knees and beg forgiveness for having fought on the losing side, this is not your book.
If you are looking for an epically honest depiction of the German grunt's viewpoint of how it felt to be driven backwards by the unstoppable masses of Russian soldiers over a period of years through the worst of living conditions, then this is more appropriate.
I have not read a more vivid description of the obscene nature of ground warfare anywhere. Nowhere else have I felt it better shown the indifferent nature of combatants as to their superiors motives or overarching goals, rather these are purely men fighting for the man next to them and merely in the hope of living to see another day. Politics and preaching are absent here...as you come to realize, they are in all trenches.
Thursday, February 19, 2015
Book Review: Zero to One by Peter Thiel
This book was one I had to hunt down on Amazon as it was not popular enough to show up in my local Barnes&Noble stores. I knew of Peter Thiel from his involvement in the formation of PayPal and his continued private equity investments. His membership in the "PayPal Mafia" is well known as are his libertarian-ish views and personal causes such as paying smart kids to NOT go to college and instead focus on a singular idea or product of their own development.
The book is written in a lecturing style which is fitting as the work is essentially a collection of his lectures to students at Stanford within a course on startups.
Within this collection are his thoughts on people like Malcolm Gladwell and John Rawls (who he thinks are pretty much boobs who focus on chance and "fairness" in their explanations for success and economics), the reason why current education and college produce a bunch of people studying everything but knowing nothing, why planning matters, how monopolies are a good thing, why successful startups contain people who are of a like mind/personality, etc. Its all quite good and I must admit, my own particular political, social and economic leanings tend to make me a fan of Thiel's ideas.
What is most important about the book is its call to arms for people to think big, to plan, to try new things, and be contrarian (though you then get the "if everyone is being contrarian, is it contrarian anymore" argument, similar to the 1990's "Alternative" music argument). Calling for a return to what he calls "definite optimism", a trait he finds in the world from the 1600's through the 1960's quoting Marx and Engels who stated that society had "created more massive and more colossal productive forces than all preceding generations together. Subjection of Nature's forces to man, machinery, application of chemistry to industry and agriculture, steam-navigation, railways, electric telegraphs, clearing of whole continents for cultivation, canalization of rivers, whole populations conjured out of the ground--what earlier century had even a presentiment that such produced forces slumbered in the lap of social labor?"
Thiel likely sees and cites herein, man's placement of 12 men on the moon as the ultimate example of planning, creation and optimism. Mentioning the plans of a 1940s schoolteacher by the name of John Reber who was a self-taught engineer and proposed a series of dams in San Francisco Bay designed to reclaim land, provide freshwater, etc. Thiel states that such a plan would never be taken seriously today but at the time the plan ended up being endorsed by newspapers across California, congressional hearings were held and the Army Corps of Engineers built a 1.5 acre scale model of the plan. The fact that such an idea from such an individual would be dismissed outright in today's society is a major failing of our current culture he feels. No longer do we welcome big plans and ask merely if they would work and instead we have turned into a society ruled by the Baby Boom generation, like Gladwell, who see little to no value in planning or individual effort but instead see only luck, happenstance, and social context.
We need more people who believe in individual exceptionalism, the ability to make one-self into whatever we wish and to dream big ideas. We need more people like Thiel and less people like Gladwell (who's book Outliers I reviewed positively here in the past) if we hope to move the human race forward. If you are developing a product or company or even just fantasize about carving your own path rather than being told what your path will be, then Zero to One is worth the read.
The book is written in a lecturing style which is fitting as the work is essentially a collection of his lectures to students at Stanford within a course on startups.
Within this collection are his thoughts on people like Malcolm Gladwell and John Rawls (who he thinks are pretty much boobs who focus on chance and "fairness" in their explanations for success and economics), the reason why current education and college produce a bunch of people studying everything but knowing nothing, why planning matters, how monopolies are a good thing, why successful startups contain people who are of a like mind/personality, etc. Its all quite good and I must admit, my own particular political, social and economic leanings tend to make me a fan of Thiel's ideas.
What is most important about the book is its call to arms for people to think big, to plan, to try new things, and be contrarian (though you then get the "if everyone is being contrarian, is it contrarian anymore" argument, similar to the 1990's "Alternative" music argument). Calling for a return to what he calls "definite optimism", a trait he finds in the world from the 1600's through the 1960's quoting Marx and Engels who stated that society had "created more massive and more colossal productive forces than all preceding generations together. Subjection of Nature's forces to man, machinery, application of chemistry to industry and agriculture, steam-navigation, railways, electric telegraphs, clearing of whole continents for cultivation, canalization of rivers, whole populations conjured out of the ground--what earlier century had even a presentiment that such produced forces slumbered in the lap of social labor?"
Thiel likely sees and cites herein, man's placement of 12 men on the moon as the ultimate example of planning, creation and optimism. Mentioning the plans of a 1940s schoolteacher by the name of John Reber who was a self-taught engineer and proposed a series of dams in San Francisco Bay designed to reclaim land, provide freshwater, etc. Thiel states that such a plan would never be taken seriously today but at the time the plan ended up being endorsed by newspapers across California, congressional hearings were held and the Army Corps of Engineers built a 1.5 acre scale model of the plan. The fact that such an idea from such an individual would be dismissed outright in today's society is a major failing of our current culture he feels. No longer do we welcome big plans and ask merely if they would work and instead we have turned into a society ruled by the Baby Boom generation, like Gladwell, who see little to no value in planning or individual effort but instead see only luck, happenstance, and social context.
We need more people who believe in individual exceptionalism, the ability to make one-self into whatever we wish and to dream big ideas. We need more people like Thiel and less people like Gladwell (who's book Outliers I reviewed positively here in the past) if we hope to move the human race forward. If you are developing a product or company or even just fantasize about carving your own path rather than being told what your path will be, then Zero to One is worth the read.
Tuesday, December 30, 2014
Book Review: Annihilation
Annihilation by Jeff Vandermeer is the first of three novels that make up the Southern Reach trilogy. I have only read this initial volume and so I don't yet know if the series comes to a satisfactory resolution or if it trails off into boring drivel.
I do know that this first work is an excellent piece of "weird fiction". There is certainly a Lovecraftian feel to the entire novel both in its use of language, style and content, though its differences are more than significant enough to stand on its own.
The story surrounds an ill fated expedition that is following in the footsteps of previous ill fated expeditions to an location dubbed "Area X". The first person speaker relaying the novel is the biologist assigned to this four woman expedition and she recounts her travels around this Area X and all the strange things we encounter. There are dolphins with human eyes, large lizard creatures waiting in the weeds, nefarious team members, microscopic parasites, strange lighthouse keepers, indescribably beautiful/horrifying/powerful creatures from seemingly another world, etc. No real explanation to many of these observations is given leaving the reader with the disquiet feeling that they only have a small insight into what is going on.
The locale of the tale is within a Southern "transition-land" between the swamps, grasses, forest and dunes bordering the ocean. The author's favorite Southern hikes taking place in the St. Marks National Wildlife reserve in Florida is the inspiration for much of the book's geography and gives the tale a great feeling of "being there" as the voice coming out of the novel has a great tone of authenticity. There is a bit of lengthy Lovecraft-like wordiness to the work which sometimes gets in the way of the story as you can be lulled into lethargy by paragraph length sentences at times, though luckily these are relatively rare.
I'm very interested in seeing where the groundwork put down in this work leads in the next two and hope the author didn't use up all his great ideas, mythmaking and mood creation on this one novel as he's certainly composed a world worth exploring further. I'll label it as my favorite fiction work of '14.
I do know that this first work is an excellent piece of "weird fiction". There is certainly a Lovecraftian feel to the entire novel both in its use of language, style and content, though its differences are more than significant enough to stand on its own.
The story surrounds an ill fated expedition that is following in the footsteps of previous ill fated expeditions to an location dubbed "Area X". The first person speaker relaying the novel is the biologist assigned to this four woman expedition and she recounts her travels around this Area X and all the strange things we encounter. There are dolphins with human eyes, large lizard creatures waiting in the weeds, nefarious team members, microscopic parasites, strange lighthouse keepers, indescribably beautiful/horrifying/powerful creatures from seemingly another world, etc. No real explanation to many of these observations is given leaving the reader with the disquiet feeling that they only have a small insight into what is going on.
The locale of the tale is within a Southern "transition-land" between the swamps, grasses, forest and dunes bordering the ocean. The author's favorite Southern hikes taking place in the St. Marks National Wildlife reserve in Florida is the inspiration for much of the book's geography and gives the tale a great feeling of "being there" as the voice coming out of the novel has a great tone of authenticity. There is a bit of lengthy Lovecraft-like wordiness to the work which sometimes gets in the way of the story as you can be lulled into lethargy by paragraph length sentences at times, though luckily these are relatively rare.
I'm very interested in seeing where the groundwork put down in this work leads in the next two and hope the author didn't use up all his great ideas, mythmaking and mood creation on this one novel as he's certainly composed a world worth exploring further. I'll label it as my favorite fiction work of '14.
Monday, April 14, 2014
Book Review: To Dakar and Back...
I was introduced to this book by one of my codrivers for the upcoming NORRA Mexican 1000 Rally, Paul Hartl who has both done the Baja 1000 in a Class 11 VW bug and is friends/acquaintances with the author of this book, Lawrence Hacking.
Mr. Hacking became the very first Canadian to complete the Dakar in 2001 on a Honda 650R as a privateer. He recaps his efforts in that rally in this book and it is a great primer for anyone looking to enter a long rally or rally-raid event. Not that it contains info on how to prepare your vehicle or give you recommended checklists for you to go through before leaving. Hacking I believe is too smart for that...he knows the way rallies and rally-raids work...you can pack everything you can ever think of and yet end up needing the single item you know you left sitting in your garage ignored in your preparations.
Instead Hacking provides enough insight and descriptions of his race in 2001 to let you know that it is perhaps your mindset, resourcefulness and ability to roll with the punches that will get you through. You can't plan away bad things from happening, instead you have to be mentally strong enough to deal with the disasters that are sure to befall you in the course of an event like these. Not that you should be haphazard or neglectful in your preparations--far from it. But you need to be wise enough to know that you don't know what you don't know...you can only be mentally prepared to deal with whatever happens. If that means you need to deal with the end of your race then that's what it means. If you need to run five miles through the desert to get a tool from a local goat herder, then you have to be ready to do so.
The book itself can sometimes run into a bit of repetition as the events Hacking describes can bear a similarity to one another from stage to stage but there is plenty of historical information regarding the Dakar, its history and its participants to keep a reader and a fan of the sport interested.
Items like the fact that 2001 winner Jutta Kleinschmidt and runner up Jean-Louis Schlesser were a romantic item before an acrimonious split that left them vicious competitors both on and off the stage, American rider Jimmie Lewis's grand effort on board a big BMW--breaking a number of bones in a crash only 200 yards from the finish in Dakar as he attempted to to win the final stage on behalf of his overmatched sponsor, and P.G. Lundmark's incredible privateer effort as well as many more anecdotes and stories are included here.
The tone of the work is straightforward and direct. There is no flowery descriptions of the action, just a matter-of-fact recounting of events. The work has made me realize the great similarities between rally-raid/rally events and another sport I love, mountaineering. Hacking often recounts the individuals he has come to know that have passed in one way or another over the years, much like the mountaineering works I have covered recount the deaths of climbers in the mountains of the world. The mental and physical strains put on the participants is strikingly familiar between the sports as is the selfish nature of each requiring vast amounts of time away from families in order to reach for some personal goal valued by a very few. Whatever the disease is that infects those who "play" at these sports, Hacking has it and describes his involvement in what is the rally-raid world's equivalent of climbing Everest or K2 with skill and candor (often covering the hypocrisy and divergence between himself and his fellow competitors and the poor of the geographies he covers). Not necessarily a book for everyone, but definitely a book for everyone involved in these sports/events.
Monday, January 6, 2014
Book Review: Fahrenheit 451
More a novella at less than 200 pages in length, Fahrenheit 451 has been edited, banned, derided, argued over, taught, and ridiculed. One thing it rarely, if ever since its publication in 1953, has been is ignored--and nor should it ever be.
Born out of McCarthy era America, post WWII and infused with a fear of "the bomb" it remains remarkably fresh to this day. Numerous critics will cite its description of "seashell" earphones as foretelling of cell phones and bluetooth headsets while the wall size "parlor walls" are eerily reminiscent of our current infatuation with ever larger flat screen TVs. The public's focus on the banal features of modern life and entertainment industry are seen here as is a society that moves from being politically correct to one of censoring thought.
And this perhaps is the biggest point that is missed in the novel. While many speak of it as a novel warning the public of governmental control and censorship this is not the root of the problem in Fahrenheit 451. Instead, the censorious and "evil" government seen in the novella is born out of society itself. It was society, as noted in the work, that began tearing various sections out of books that they found offensive. As group by group by group was seen to have equal standing in terms of being "hurt" by the written word, so it was that EVERYTHING must be removed from public consumption so that NO ONE was offended. Thus, the government became merely a proper representation of the public's desire. Society WANTED to focus on only the trivial, the meaningless, the comforting, the easy--and thus government followed suit. In Fahrenheit 451 it was not the government that force society to be this way--it was the inverse.
This perspective on the book is give further weight towards the end where the protagonist, Montag, is recounted a story about the Phoenix who DESTROYS HIMSELF, only to rise again as well as the desire for there to be built massive mirror factories for society to look at themselves in. Again and again Bradbury tells us the problem is US, and only by extension, the government.
I rarely sing high praises for any work, but here its worth it. Short, direct, prescient, and frightening in its depiction of our modern world, Fahrenheit 451 is everything that a person--particularly a young person (in actual age or just in mindset) should be reading.
Born out of McCarthy era America, post WWII and infused with a fear of "the bomb" it remains remarkably fresh to this day. Numerous critics will cite its description of "seashell" earphones as foretelling of cell phones and bluetooth headsets while the wall size "parlor walls" are eerily reminiscent of our current infatuation with ever larger flat screen TVs. The public's focus on the banal features of modern life and entertainment industry are seen here as is a society that moves from being politically correct to one of censoring thought.
And this perhaps is the biggest point that is missed in the novel. While many speak of it as a novel warning the public of governmental control and censorship this is not the root of the problem in Fahrenheit 451. Instead, the censorious and "evil" government seen in the novella is born out of society itself. It was society, as noted in the work, that began tearing various sections out of books that they found offensive. As group by group by group was seen to have equal standing in terms of being "hurt" by the written word, so it was that EVERYTHING must be removed from public consumption so that NO ONE was offended. Thus, the government became merely a proper representation of the public's desire. Society WANTED to focus on only the trivial, the meaningless, the comforting, the easy--and thus government followed suit. In Fahrenheit 451 it was not the government that force society to be this way--it was the inverse.
This perspective on the book is give further weight towards the end where the protagonist, Montag, is recounted a story about the Phoenix who DESTROYS HIMSELF, only to rise again as well as the desire for there to be built massive mirror factories for society to look at themselves in. Again and again Bradbury tells us the problem is US, and only by extension, the government.
I rarely sing high praises for any work, but here its worth it. Short, direct, prescient, and frightening in its depiction of our modern world, Fahrenheit 451 is everything that a person--particularly a young person (in actual age or just in mindset) should be reading.
Sunday, November 3, 2013
Book Review: Fatal Journey--The Final Expedition of Henry Hudson
I've always had a thing for the northern explorers.
Whether its because of my more Anglo Saxon roots or my New England birthplace and frequent visits to Canada, I've always been more interested in those European explorers who ventured into the colder climes of North America than the more southernly focused efforts.
Henry Hudson completed a number of journeys to North America as well as Northern Russia, Greenland, Iceland, etc. His name remains marked on New York's largest river and one of the largest bays in the world. While Fatal Journey: The Final Expedition of Henry Hudson by Peter Mancall focuses on his final voyage to the "New World" it contains sufficient history surrounding his other journeys as well as those of similar explorers--Frobisher, Champlain, etc. that it serves as a good base of knowledge of all early European, Nordic explorers.
The book also serves as a good education on the reasoning behind the efforts of these explorers and their political and economic backers. While I had always known that the search for the Northwest Passage (and European exploration of the New World in general) was driven by a search for a quicker way to the products available in the South Pacific, I guess I hadn't really known or thought about the fact that these products were "just" spices. All that effort, lives, money, industry were spent in an effort to bring back food flavorings. Well, not just food flavorings but "medicine" as well. Beyond the culinary applications of the various South Seas spices, most of these products were also viewed as "cure alls" for whatever ailed you in the 14th+ century. Yup...pepper, curry, etc. were used to "cure" the plague, indigestion, headaches, flatulence, etc. If you were ill, there was a spice that cured your sickness. So in truth, the discovery and exploration of the Western hemisphere by Europeans was driven by a bunch of quacks.
While there might be a bit of humor to be found in some of the reasons behind our continents unmasking, the efforts to do so were decidedly without humor and often life threatening. Most oceangoing trips would return with a few less sailors on board than what they started with (sometimes a the hands of the decidedly NOT always peaceful indigenous population), yet finding a ship full of those willing to venture into the unknown doesn't seem to have been a problem.
Hudson's final arctic exploration would end in disaster. Hudson's crew revolted, put him and his teenage son (and others) in a skiff and left them for dead. Hudson never found the Northwest passage he was looking for. Neither his body nor his fate were ever truly revealed. Those who returned to England blamed other members of the crew who "happened" to have died on the trip back and no one was ever held accountable. Hudson was a failure. As were other explorations--Jacques Cartier's third voyage bringing back a ship full of quartz and Fool's Gold (instead of the diamonds and gold he thought it was) comes to mind. If it weren't for these brave failures however, the human race would still be plucking fleas out of its unshaven mane.
This work is a solid and interesting work covering a whole range of efforts in the search for the Northwest (and Northeast) passage. Anyone interested in either Hudson or early North America exploration should value this effort.
Whether its because of my more Anglo Saxon roots or my New England birthplace and frequent visits to Canada, I've always been more interested in those European explorers who ventured into the colder climes of North America than the more southernly focused efforts.
Henry Hudson completed a number of journeys to North America as well as Northern Russia, Greenland, Iceland, etc. His name remains marked on New York's largest river and one of the largest bays in the world. While Fatal Journey: The Final Expedition of Henry Hudson by Peter Mancall focuses on his final voyage to the "New World" it contains sufficient history surrounding his other journeys as well as those of similar explorers--Frobisher, Champlain, etc. that it serves as a good base of knowledge of all early European, Nordic explorers.
The book also serves as a good education on the reasoning behind the efforts of these explorers and their political and economic backers. While I had always known that the search for the Northwest Passage (and European exploration of the New World in general) was driven by a search for a quicker way to the products available in the South Pacific, I guess I hadn't really known or thought about the fact that these products were "just" spices. All that effort, lives, money, industry were spent in an effort to bring back food flavorings. Well, not just food flavorings but "medicine" as well. Beyond the culinary applications of the various South Seas spices, most of these products were also viewed as "cure alls" for whatever ailed you in the 14th+ century. Yup...pepper, curry, etc. were used to "cure" the plague, indigestion, headaches, flatulence, etc. If you were ill, there was a spice that cured your sickness. So in truth, the discovery and exploration of the Western hemisphere by Europeans was driven by a bunch of quacks.
While there might be a bit of humor to be found in some of the reasons behind our continents unmasking, the efforts to do so were decidedly without humor and often life threatening. Most oceangoing trips would return with a few less sailors on board than what they started with (sometimes a the hands of the decidedly NOT always peaceful indigenous population), yet finding a ship full of those willing to venture into the unknown doesn't seem to have been a problem.
Hudson's final arctic exploration would end in disaster. Hudson's crew revolted, put him and his teenage son (and others) in a skiff and left them for dead. Hudson never found the Northwest passage he was looking for. Neither his body nor his fate were ever truly revealed. Those who returned to England blamed other members of the crew who "happened" to have died on the trip back and no one was ever held accountable. Hudson was a failure. As were other explorations--Jacques Cartier's third voyage bringing back a ship full of quartz and Fool's Gold (instead of the diamonds and gold he thought it was) comes to mind. If it weren't for these brave failures however, the human race would still be plucking fleas out of its unshaven mane.
This work is a solid and interesting work covering a whole range of efforts in the search for the Northwest (and Northeast) passage. Anyone interested in either Hudson or early North America exploration should value this effort.
Wednesday, October 9, 2013
Book Review: Caliban's War and Abaddon's Gate
I decided to do this review and include both of these novels as they finish up the Expanse Trilogy that I began with the earlier review of Leviathan Wakes a bit over a month back.While S.A. Corey's initial novel in this series was very entertaining and a complete work in its own right, the follow ups are less baked. Leviathan Wakes saw the death of its strongest character, detective Miller, and the rest of the series suffers for it.
Caliban's War and Abaddon's Gate centers on Jim Holden and the other crewmembers of his ship. Holden is too "good" to be a main character...he is given no flaws other than his "goodness" and "honesty"...not real great flaws to generate action within a novel.
Additional problems arise in the story itself. While Leviathan Wakes largely focused on a traditional "missing person" hunt and alternated between two characters, the next two novels either repeat that same premise (the missing person) or wander off into an underdeveloped premise without anything remotely close to a satisfactory resolution while adding a bunch of weaker characters to the mix.
Both novels lose the impressive world building nature of Leviathan Wakes and no longer feel fresh while the invasion of the solar system by an alien weapon system dispatched billions of years ago, falls almost to the wayside in both works and the story focuses on almost solely the human to human intrigue--which is a large part of the unresolved nature of the entire series. Everything that Leviathan Wakes builds towards is left hanging in the next two novels with little learned and nothing gained.
I wish I could recommend these two novels and the series as a whole. The series isn't a total loss as there are certainly ideas and themes here that are valuable--particularly the "world" building contained within the initial novel. The descriptions of how humanity moved out into the solar system and the conflicts and machinations that occur with that move are extremely well done. If possible, the series might have been better hewing even closer to a more traditional military/whodunit style of works. The authors don't do a great job with their big driver of the series--the alien "protomolecule" and thus...it ultimately isn't worth it.
Saturday, August 31, 2013
Book Review: Leviathan Wakes
Written by the combination of Daniel Abraham and Ty Franck under the pen name of James S.S. Corey (why?), Leviathan Wakes is one of the first large form Sci-Fi books I've written in quite some time and one of the most entertaining I've ever read.
Make no mistake, this isn't "hard" sci-fi. You won't be getting into multipage descriptions of the technological minutiae of a propulsion drive or the math required to calculate the force necessary to move a heavenly body out of its orbit.
What you do get is a fully formed and eminently believable "world" in which the story functions. Extrapolating from today's space technology, political machinations and corporate expansion, Corey weaves an extremely detailed pathway for his characters to ride.
Corey also does a fantastic job of literally weaving the story together--taking two characters and alternating chapters between them until they come together later in the story and then towards the end returning to the alternating perspective as the characters again are separated. The convention works well and lends itself well to holding the reader's attention.
The story itself involves the hunt for a missing woman and the eventual conspiracy that is uncovered as being responsible for her death (? here as I'm not sure she really "dies"). You have all the typical features of a great sci-fi story with space battles, weird creatures, items floating around, the danger of space's vacuum, etc. In fact, much of the story carries familiar aspects that we've all encountered elsewhere--whether its in Alien, Blade Runner, 28 Days Later, Outbreak, etc. Corey is not exactly breaking new ground in terms of storytelling but he has wrapped together a number of genres into a very entertaining package.
With Leviathan Wakes being the first novel in a trilogy, it does what it sets out to do--which is to get you looking for the next chance you get to buy the followup.
Make no mistake, this isn't "hard" sci-fi. You won't be getting into multipage descriptions of the technological minutiae of a propulsion drive or the math required to calculate the force necessary to move a heavenly body out of its orbit.
What you do get is a fully formed and eminently believable "world" in which the story functions. Extrapolating from today's space technology, political machinations and corporate expansion, Corey weaves an extremely detailed pathway for his characters to ride.
Corey also does a fantastic job of literally weaving the story together--taking two characters and alternating chapters between them until they come together later in the story and then towards the end returning to the alternating perspective as the characters again are separated. The convention works well and lends itself well to holding the reader's attention.
The story itself involves the hunt for a missing woman and the eventual conspiracy that is uncovered as being responsible for her death (? here as I'm not sure she really "dies"). You have all the typical features of a great sci-fi story with space battles, weird creatures, items floating around, the danger of space's vacuum, etc. In fact, much of the story carries familiar aspects that we've all encountered elsewhere--whether its in Alien, Blade Runner, 28 Days Later, Outbreak, etc. Corey is not exactly breaking new ground in terms of storytelling but he has wrapped together a number of genres into a very entertaining package.
With Leviathan Wakes being the first novel in a trilogy, it does what it sets out to do--which is to get you looking for the next chance you get to buy the followup.
Thursday, August 1, 2013
Book Review: The Skies Belong to Us
As a long time fan of Wired magazine (I was a subscriber from issue #1 for many years before my interest in all things computer related waned but have been following them more closely again as they have branched out into so many other areas) seeing that the author of this book possessed some Wired pedigree got me beyond just viewing the front cover as I knew it would be well written and interesting.
I was not disappointed. Brendan Koerner uses one airline hijacking in particular to delve into the whole skyjacking phenomenon prevalent throughout the 60's and 70's. From the reluctance of the airlines to submit to passenger screenings to the sometimes off the hinges methods behind the skyjackings, Koerner covers it all with humor and insight. This is not to say the the book is funny, its not. Its just that its overall attitude is an off the cuff, slightly irreverent one that I enjoy.
One comes away from the book understanding why skyjacking rose in prominence and frequency during this period and why it is nearly extinct today. In today's world of undressing, full body scans, explosive material wipedowns, confiscation of water bottles, etc. it seems downright amazing that in 70's individuals were allowed to board unscreened, unsearched and virtually unquestioned. Carrying a loaded gun onto a plane?? Sure, have at it!!
Not only that but the policies in place by both the airlines and the federal government virtually ensured via their complete capitulation to the hijackers on all terms and conditions (a million dollars?? Sure!! Here you go!) that the numbers and severity of the instances would only increase.
While the book focuses on the hijacking of a plane in California by a Richard Holder (African American, Vietnam Vet with delusions of the many and varied kind) and Cathy Kerkow (a white, hippy, moron--are there any other kind?) and its resulting attempt to free a communist philosophy teacher from her murder charges while absconding with $500,000 at first to North Vietnam and when that didn't work out, to Algeria where they would join the Black Panther leadership in exile and eventually gain asylum in France where they were lauded by all sorts of left wing sympathizers (Jean Paul Sartre as one amongst many).
The story of these two wanna be world changers ends with more of a whimper than a bang (best thing to be said of them is that they never directly injured anyone during their escapades) but by that point you are satisfied with the book because you've learned so much. The advent of modern day airport security, the end of hijacking as we knew it (until 9/11), the collapse of Cuba as a haven for American terrorists, the virus spreading like nature of skyjackings, etc. It is shocking to someone of my age to find out that during the late 60's and early 70's that there could generally be said to occur a skyjacking on American soil every week. Compare that to the 1990's where there wasn't a single skyjacking in the entire decade and you realize the massive change that has occurred. Prior to reading this book I thought the famed case of DB Cooper (the guy who got a ransom and then parachuted out of a plane with said ransom into the wilds of the American Northwest, never to be found) was a one off instance--turns out it was one of MANY instances where hijackers commandeered an airplane, received money and jumped from the plane with a parachute (to one level of success or another). I was dumbfounded. You mean there was a time in recent history where people were routinely taking over planes, obtaining six figures ransom sums and parachuting out all around the country?? That's insane! And sometimes it takes a quality bit of reporting and storytelling to bring the craziness of our recent, overlooked history to light.
I was not disappointed. Brendan Koerner uses one airline hijacking in particular to delve into the whole skyjacking phenomenon prevalent throughout the 60's and 70's. From the reluctance of the airlines to submit to passenger screenings to the sometimes off the hinges methods behind the skyjackings, Koerner covers it all with humor and insight. This is not to say the the book is funny, its not. Its just that its overall attitude is an off the cuff, slightly irreverent one that I enjoy.
One comes away from the book understanding why skyjacking rose in prominence and frequency during this period and why it is nearly extinct today. In today's world of undressing, full body scans, explosive material wipedowns, confiscation of water bottles, etc. it seems downright amazing that in 70's individuals were allowed to board unscreened, unsearched and virtually unquestioned. Carrying a loaded gun onto a plane?? Sure, have at it!!
Not only that but the policies in place by both the airlines and the federal government virtually ensured via their complete capitulation to the hijackers on all terms and conditions (a million dollars?? Sure!! Here you go!) that the numbers and severity of the instances would only increase.
While the book focuses on the hijacking of a plane in California by a Richard Holder (African American, Vietnam Vet with delusions of the many and varied kind) and Cathy Kerkow (a white, hippy, moron--are there any other kind?) and its resulting attempt to free a communist philosophy teacher from her murder charges while absconding with $500,000 at first to North Vietnam and when that didn't work out, to Algeria where they would join the Black Panther leadership in exile and eventually gain asylum in France where they were lauded by all sorts of left wing sympathizers (Jean Paul Sartre as one amongst many).
The story of these two wanna be world changers ends with more of a whimper than a bang (best thing to be said of them is that they never directly injured anyone during their escapades) but by that point you are satisfied with the book because you've learned so much. The advent of modern day airport security, the end of hijacking as we knew it (until 9/11), the collapse of Cuba as a haven for American terrorists, the virus spreading like nature of skyjackings, etc. It is shocking to someone of my age to find out that during the late 60's and early 70's that there could generally be said to occur a skyjacking on American soil every week. Compare that to the 1990's where there wasn't a single skyjacking in the entire decade and you realize the massive change that has occurred. Prior to reading this book I thought the famed case of DB Cooper (the guy who got a ransom and then parachuted out of a plane with said ransom into the wilds of the American Northwest, never to be found) was a one off instance--turns out it was one of MANY instances where hijackers commandeered an airplane, received money and jumped from the plane with a parachute (to one level of success or another). I was dumbfounded. You mean there was a time in recent history where people were routinely taking over planes, obtaining six figures ransom sums and parachuting out all around the country?? That's insane! And sometimes it takes a quality bit of reporting and storytelling to bring the craziness of our recent, overlooked history to light.
Tuesday, July 23, 2013
Book Review: Lost in Shangri-La
Lost in Shangri-La sounded like an interesting book--a crashed military flight leaving a handful of survivors amidst an unmapped area of a tropical island filled with cannibals and Japanese soldiers. Yup, it sounds interesting till you get into the details.
The plane wasn't shot down, the pilots screwed up and flew it into a mountainside. The plane wasn't on a military mission they were out sightseeing. The area may have been generally unmapped but it was known well enough to have earned nicknames and numerous overflights. The Japanese soldiers that were left on the island were hiding in the jungle hoping to survive without resupply or support from the mainland. The cannibals might have eaten each other after battle but had little to no interest in the white people who crashed into their midst.
The author sets up all of the dangers present to both the survivors and those who came to rescue them--its just that none of those dangers ever really occur. The survivors and those who parachuted in to assist them spent a relatively comfortable and safe time recuperating and then were whisked out of the jungle on a specially mocked up glider.
The book just never really captured my attention. The writing was adequate but nothing more than perfunctory descriptions of events and backgrounds. You can tell he's really desperate for something to really happen in his tale...its just that nothing ever does.
Is the book worth a quick recap of a somewhat interesting sidebar event that occurred during WWII? Sure, but an entire novel and being declared "The Most Incredible Rescue Mission of WWII" on its cover gives away its pretense at trying to be another best selling WWII tale that the public can't seem to get enough of--this one just isn't quite worth it and certainly not at some 300 pages, much of which is unremarkable filler.
Thursday, June 6, 2013
Book Review: Into the Silence by Wade Davis
I've read a good deal of non-fiction over the past few years, a lot of it revolving around military history and another good portion of it around outdoor adventures. Into the Silence covers both topics and covers them in a manner better than any work I've come across.
Truly a staggering achievement, Davis' book was seemingly marketed toward the Into Thin Air crowd--not that there is anything wrong with that--but this book covers so much more than just Mallory and Irvine's ill fated attempt at Everest in 1924.
It covers not only the 1924 expedition but the series of exploratory expeditions and attempts in the years leading up to the 1924 edition as well as the participants upbringings and particularly their experiences in WWI. Its hard to describe just how comprehensive Davis' work is. Davis goes through all the members of all the expeditions amounting to several dozen individuals and doesn't skimp on the information provided on any of them. Details are pulled from personal diaries, military documentation, interviews with descendants, films, photography and a seemingly endless list of other sources. Everything is detailed in the copious appendixes though the work is not simply a regurgitation of other peoples facts and figures.
Davis tells this story with a flair. He sets the groundwork and background of the period in which these individuals grew up in and where they came from. He details the affect being brought up in privileged, private, all boys schools had on them, how their war experiences changed their world views, how they interacted with the Tibetans they encountered on the expeditions. Everything is here.
And its anything but boring. Davis includes absolutely horrific experiences of the trenches and covers a great deal of WWI history (you could do worse in learning about WWI than reading this non-military history book) and wonderful scenes of exploration across Tibet. Which is also an integral part of this work--the history of England and the Raj and their interactions with Tibet. Again, the coverage of England's relationships with Russia and China and others are covered here as well as English politics of the time. Really there is so much that is covered here its insane and the fact that it is so entertaining makes it the best piece of non-fiction I have perhaps ever read. If you have any interest in WWI, England, Tibet, Everest, Mallory, etc. then you owe it to yourself to read this book.
Truly a staggering achievement, Davis' book was seemingly marketed toward the Into Thin Air crowd--not that there is anything wrong with that--but this book covers so much more than just Mallory and Irvine's ill fated attempt at Everest in 1924.
It covers not only the 1924 expedition but the series of exploratory expeditions and attempts in the years leading up to the 1924 edition as well as the participants upbringings and particularly their experiences in WWI. Its hard to describe just how comprehensive Davis' work is. Davis goes through all the members of all the expeditions amounting to several dozen individuals and doesn't skimp on the information provided on any of them. Details are pulled from personal diaries, military documentation, interviews with descendants, films, photography and a seemingly endless list of other sources. Everything is detailed in the copious appendixes though the work is not simply a regurgitation of other peoples facts and figures.
Davis tells this story with a flair. He sets the groundwork and background of the period in which these individuals grew up in and where they came from. He details the affect being brought up in privileged, private, all boys schools had on them, how their war experiences changed their world views, how they interacted with the Tibetans they encountered on the expeditions. Everything is here.
And its anything but boring. Davis includes absolutely horrific experiences of the trenches and covers a great deal of WWI history (you could do worse in learning about WWI than reading this non-military history book) and wonderful scenes of exploration across Tibet. Which is also an integral part of this work--the history of England and the Raj and their interactions with Tibet. Again, the coverage of England's relationships with Russia and China and others are covered here as well as English politics of the time. Really there is so much that is covered here its insane and the fact that it is so entertaining makes it the best piece of non-fiction I have perhaps ever read. If you have any interest in WWI, England, Tibet, Everest, Mallory, etc. then you owe it to yourself to read this book.
Thursday, May 30, 2013
Book Review: A Dawn Like Thunder
This focused and personal account of of one specific flight group in the Pacific during WWII covers in detail what can be argued to be the two most pivotal battles of that campaign.
The Battle of Midway and the Guadalcanal campaign can be viewed as the turning points in the naval and ground efforts and torpedo squadron eight played a key role in each.
Author Rober Mrazek pulls no punches in this work, feeling free to critique all levels of the Naval forces involved--from individual squadron commanders to full blown Admirals, none who deserve blame escape it.
And that's perhaps the most revelatory part of the book--that the US forces could be mismanaged, misdirected and poorly lead and yet still, due to both luck and skill, end up victorious. Torpedo Squadron Eight benefited from both of these factors to become the most decorated group of Naval aviators in US history.
Initially assigned outdated and outclassed aircraft the fliers of this squadron were often presented with suicidal missions and faced them without hesitation. There is no real happy ending here as virtually every individual Mrazek introduces you to via devoted chapters will meet their fate either via accident, flak or the hands of a skilled Japanese pilot. The chances of returning alive from taking part in both of these battles seems to be nearly zero.
A Dawn Like Thunder is a solid work covering a detailed look at one specific unit during two key events of a long campaign. It covers these events from the 100,000 foot level in terms of overall strategy, movements and decisions to focus on a smaller group of individuals. This doesn't make the book bad, just a tad limited in its scope. If you already know the basics of Midway and Guadalcanal this book makes an excellent addition to your detailed knowledge of the events, but make sure you obtain a broader view of these events from other works as well.
The Battle of Midway and the Guadalcanal campaign can be viewed as the turning points in the naval and ground efforts and torpedo squadron eight played a key role in each.
Author Rober Mrazek pulls no punches in this work, feeling free to critique all levels of the Naval forces involved--from individual squadron commanders to full blown Admirals, none who deserve blame escape it.
And that's perhaps the most revelatory part of the book--that the US forces could be mismanaged, misdirected and poorly lead and yet still, due to both luck and skill, end up victorious. Torpedo Squadron Eight benefited from both of these factors to become the most decorated group of Naval aviators in US history.
Initially assigned outdated and outclassed aircraft the fliers of this squadron were often presented with suicidal missions and faced them without hesitation. There is no real happy ending here as virtually every individual Mrazek introduces you to via devoted chapters will meet their fate either via accident, flak or the hands of a skilled Japanese pilot. The chances of returning alive from taking part in both of these battles seems to be nearly zero.
A Dawn Like Thunder is a solid work covering a detailed look at one specific unit during two key events of a long campaign. It covers these events from the 100,000 foot level in terms of overall strategy, movements and decisions to focus on a smaller group of individuals. This doesn't make the book bad, just a tad limited in its scope. If you already know the basics of Midway and Guadalcanal this book makes an excellent addition to your detailed knowledge of the events, but make sure you obtain a broader view of these events from other works as well.
Thursday, January 3, 2013
Book Review--The Financial Lives of the Poets by Jess Walter
OK, maybe I just don't "get" book reviews...
I went searching for book reviews for The Financial Lives of the Poets to see some other viewpoints on the novel. Thing is...most don't really tell you their opinion of the novel. Almost like the authors are scared to say ANYTHING good or bad about it. And we're talking the supposed educated, in the know, class of reviewers in editions of the NY Times and Washington Post here!! Surely they should be able to tell you whether they even have an opinion on a work or not, shouldn't they?
Alas, no...instead what you get is a couple hundred words summarizing the plot in a fashion no different than reading the back cover or inside leaf of the book (should you be purchasing hardcover!) and then tell you that its "whip smart with bleeding edge current references", blah, blah, blah, and never getting to whether its truly worth your time.
Not here. Contrived and recycled. There. Lets begin.
So a poor newspaper journalist and his wife overextended themselves by purchasing a large house, sending their kids to private school and a car they didn't need. Then when said journalist tries to start an ill fated website that merged poetry with financial advice and subsequently loses the newspaper job to which he was forced to return, his life is a shit-show.
That's the basic starting point for Jess Walter's satirical novel. The supposed "giggle giggle" solution to all this mess for the protagonist is to turn to selling pot via a group of young malcontents he meets one night on his way to buy milk!! Holy cow!! Isn't that funny!! A suburban, upper middle class white guy has to turn to selling drugs to keep his house from getting foreclosed upon and his car repossessed!! Wow!
OK, so some might say this is satire and that I missed the point of the humor. I didn't. It isn't funny. Its been used--Weeds, Breaking Bad, etc. to name a few in current times at the very least (I'm not up on my drug culture media references).
Its not only the retread of an idea that really isn't new to begin with that is a problem here, its the entire tone of the novel. It came as no shock to me in reading a section about the author that HE is a newspaperman himself. To call the novel a personal screed would be closer to the truth than calling it a satire. As the protagonist "wonders" how he (and by inference the rest of the country) got into such a mess, you wonder "Why on earth didn't the author just write in with his thoughts to the Op-Ed page of the NYT rather than writing this novel?"
As a satire the novel doesn't bring any "wow" factor to analyzing the situation our country found/finds itself in, nor is the author brave enough to lay the blame at any one's feet. Like his high protagonist the author waffles this way and that, kinda blaming everyone and no one at the same time. If he targets any one cause for our populous's financial woes its our American consumption and "keeping up with the Joneses" mentality. The phrase "keeping up with the Joneses" is one that is about 100 years old at this point...the "satire" contained within this novel is nearly as old, and stale...
The language Walter uses to craft the novel is clear, modern and concise. His descriptions of characters and modern living are fairly spot one. It is unfortunate that the premise behind the novel and the author's inability to craft a new idea or insightful criticism of modern society leave it so hobbled.
I went searching for book reviews for The Financial Lives of the Poets to see some other viewpoints on the novel. Thing is...most don't really tell you their opinion of the novel. Almost like the authors are scared to say ANYTHING good or bad about it. And we're talking the supposed educated, in the know, class of reviewers in editions of the NY Times and Washington Post here!! Surely they should be able to tell you whether they even have an opinion on a work or not, shouldn't they?
Alas, no...instead what you get is a couple hundred words summarizing the plot in a fashion no different than reading the back cover or inside leaf of the book (should you be purchasing hardcover!) and then tell you that its "whip smart with bleeding edge current references", blah, blah, blah, and never getting to whether its truly worth your time.
Not here. Contrived and recycled. There. Lets begin.
So a poor newspaper journalist and his wife overextended themselves by purchasing a large house, sending their kids to private school and a car they didn't need. Then when said journalist tries to start an ill fated website that merged poetry with financial advice and subsequently loses the newspaper job to which he was forced to return, his life is a shit-show.
That's the basic starting point for Jess Walter's satirical novel. The supposed "giggle giggle" solution to all this mess for the protagonist is to turn to selling pot via a group of young malcontents he meets one night on his way to buy milk!! Holy cow!! Isn't that funny!! A suburban, upper middle class white guy has to turn to selling drugs to keep his house from getting foreclosed upon and his car repossessed!! Wow!
OK, so some might say this is satire and that I missed the point of the humor. I didn't. It isn't funny. Its been used--Weeds, Breaking Bad, etc. to name a few in current times at the very least (I'm not up on my drug culture media references).
Its not only the retread of an idea that really isn't new to begin with that is a problem here, its the entire tone of the novel. It came as no shock to me in reading a section about the author that HE is a newspaperman himself. To call the novel a personal screed would be closer to the truth than calling it a satire. As the protagonist "wonders" how he (and by inference the rest of the country) got into such a mess, you wonder "Why on earth didn't the author just write in with his thoughts to the Op-Ed page of the NYT rather than writing this novel?"
As a satire the novel doesn't bring any "wow" factor to analyzing the situation our country found/finds itself in, nor is the author brave enough to lay the blame at any one's feet. Like his high protagonist the author waffles this way and that, kinda blaming everyone and no one at the same time. If he targets any one cause for our populous's financial woes its our American consumption and "keeping up with the Joneses" mentality. The phrase "keeping up with the Joneses" is one that is about 100 years old at this point...the "satire" contained within this novel is nearly as old, and stale...
The language Walter uses to craft the novel is clear, modern and concise. His descriptions of characters and modern living are fairly spot one. It is unfortunate that the premise behind the novel and the author's inability to craft a new idea or insightful criticism of modern society leave it so hobbled.
Sunday, November 30, 2008
Book Review: Long Way Down
Ahhh, what a great tale the back cover of this book promises--Two great friends hop on their BMW's and head off from the Northern tip of Scotland and many weeks and 15,000 miles later they end up at the end of the road in South Africa. What sites they must see!! What great anecdotes they must have!! What trials and tribulations they must undergo!! Ummm...not so much.....
Having heard of Ewan McGregor (of Star Wars and Trainspotting fame) and Charley Boorman's (a previous Dakar entrant and son of Deliverance director John Boorman) previous trip which was entitled "Long Way Around" and the good press its book and TV series received, I was excited to read this book. My expectations coming in were that it would contain stories of the exotic locals they were sure to travel through in Africa and mix in the difficulties and unexpected events that are sure to take place on any such long distance trip that involves large offroad/dirt road sections. I will not disparage the thinking that went into the trip's development as the trip itself raised funds for a number of worthy causes and awareness of even more.
What I will critique is the writing of the book itself. Whether it is a lack of writing experience or a lack of actual interesting events taking place during the trip, the book is quite uneventful and slow...For all the distance traveled, very little happens to the pair that wouldn't happen to nearly anyone on a trip to their local offroad park. A few spills, a few punctures and thats about it. Good for them...bad for the reader. Its hard to get excited over "We road 150 miles today from X to X and there were a few potholes and rocks. Then we stopped for coffee and set up our tents and went to bed..." Great......
Of the two writers, Boorman comes off as the far more likeable and the guy you would rather share a few beers with...Though McGregor is the better known and more wealthy, it is Boorman who has a more pragmatic outlook on the world and is less prone to silly statements like "Though I've lived in England all my life, I never imagined that people ACTUALLY lived in such poverty and poor conditions!!" (a bit of a paraphrase, but you get the point...).
I might have a different opinion if this was the video version of their trip as I'd at least get the visuals of all the places they visited (Pyramids, Greek ruins, Nile river, African wildlife, etc.) but as a book it relies solely upon its authors, who in this case cannot get their words to match the splendors they observed and thus we are left with a book whose reach far exceeds its grasp.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)













